Valvoline vs Take 5 Oil Change: What’s Included, Which Oil, and How the Visits Differ (November 2026)

Short answer: both chains keep you in the driver’s seat, take no appointment, and publish almost nothing about price. What drivers actually pay varies by store, so we track it separately on our Valvoline oil change prices and Take 5 oil change prices pages. The real difference is what you can see in writing before you pull in.

Valvoline publishes a numbered 18-point maintenance check, a five-quart limit, and the exact oil product lines it pours. Take 5 publishes a shorter included list, names no oil brand at all, and claims the faster visit. In the JD Power 2026 satisfaction study, drivers score Take 5 a little higher.

  • Deepest documented service: Valvoline, with its published 18-point check
  • Fastest claimed visit: Take 5, about 10 minutes, framed as the whole visit
  • Oil you can research in advance: Valvoline; Take 5 does not publish its oil brand
  • Biggest network: Valvoline, more than 2,500 locations against over 1,400
  • Higher driver score: Take 5, 833 of 1,000 against 823 (JD Power, 2026)

Valvoline vs Take 5 at a Glance

Valvoline Instant Oil ChangeTake 5 Oil Change
Service modelDrive-thru, stay in your carDrive-thru, stay in your car
Published time claimAbout 15 minutesAbout 10 minutes
What the claim measuresThe oil change itselfThe whole visit
Included with the oil change18-point maintenance check, published as a numbered listShort published list: top-offs, tire pressure, filter and wiper inspection
Quart rulePublished: up to 5 quarts included, extra quarts cost extraNot published: refill matches the manufacturer’s requirements
Oil brandIts own, with five named product linesNot published
Free top-offs between visitsWidely offered at store level, not published as a national policyNot published
Service warranty on the national websiteNot publishedNot published
LocationsMore than 2,500 across the US and CanadaOver 1,400 across North America
JD Power 2026 score (quick oil change)823 of 1,000, tied for third833 of 1,000, second

One warranty note, because neither website answers it: Valvoline’s limited service warranty is printed on the receipt rather than published online, and a franchisee describes it as 3 months or 3,000 miles. Take 5’s warranty, 30 days or 1,000 miles, has appeared in company press statements but is not published on take5.com.

What’s in the Jug: Which Oil Goes Into Your Engine?

This is the difference no other comparison for this pairing spells out. Valvoline is the manufacturer of the oil it pours, and it publishes the lineup. Take 5 publishes no oil brand anywhere on its website, so there is nothing to research or request in advance.

Valvoline’s named passenger-car lines, and who each one is built for:

  • Daily Protection: the standard conventional and synthetic blend oils for everyday driving.
  • MaxLife: a blend and a full synthetic made for engines over 75,000 miles, the chain’s high-mileage answer.
  • Advanced Full Synthetic: the mainstream full synthetic tier.
  • Extended Protection Full Synthetic: the longer-interval full synthetic tier.
  • Restore & Protect Premium Full Synthetic: the flagship, marketed as removing up to 100 percent of piston deposits over repeated use.

Valvoline also runs a published engine guarantee program for its oils: tiered engine coverage up to 300,000 miles, tied to using a qualifying Valvoline oil on schedule. That is a guarantee on the oil, not a warranty on the shop visit, and the two should not be confused.

At Take 5, the services page says technicians will help you pick the right oil type, and it sells the usual four types: conventional, synthetic blend, full synthetic and high mileage. It names no brand and no product line. For many drivers that silence is fine. If your engine is high mileage, or you care about deposits and want to read up on the exact oil before the visit, only one of these two chains lets you.

What Does Each Oil Change Actually Include?

Valvoline publishes its maintenance check as a numbered 18-point list. Take 5 publishes a short list of what comes with an oil change. Here are the two lists mapped item by item, checked against both companies’ own pages on November 13, 2026:

ItemValvolineTake 5
Oil and a standard filterIncluded, up to 5 quartsIncluded, filled to the manufacturer’s requirements
Chassis lubricationIncludedNot listed
Air filterCheckedInspected
Cabin air filterChecked, if requestedNot listed
Wiper bladesCheckedInspected
Tire pressureCheckedChecked
Windshield washer fluidCheckedTopped off
Coolant (radiator fluid)CheckedTopped off
Power steering fluidCheckedTopped off
Brake fluidCheckedNot listed
Automatic transmission fluidCheckedNot listed
Differential fluidsChecked, if requestedNot listed
BatteryTested, at participating locationsNot listed
Headlights and taillightsCheckedNot listed
Oil change reminder lightResetNot listed
Under-hood and under-chassis lookVisual inspectionNot listed

How to read that map: where Valvoline checks a fluid level, Take 5 often tops the fluid off instead, which is its own kind of value. What Take 5 does not do, on its own published list, is range across the brake, transmission, differential, battery and lights items that Valvoline writes down.

Two more differences hide in the fine print of the lists themselves:

  • The quart rule. Valvoline publishes its cap: up to 5 quarts are included, and quarts beyond five cost extra, as do premium or canister filters. Take 5 publishes no quart allowance at all; its site says the refill matches your manufacturer’s requirements.
  • The footnotes. Valvoline’s check applies to items that are accessible and applicable, at participating locations, and the check does not measure tire tread depth. Take 5’s list is shorter, but it carries fewer conditions.

Small comfort worth knowing: Take 5 locations hand drivers bottled water during the visit. Valvoline publishes no equivalent touch.

Is Take 5 Really Faster Than Valvoline?

On paper, yes, by five minutes. The two claims do not quite measure the same thing.

Valvoline’s published claim is about 15 minutes, and its store FAQ words it as the service itself: the full-service oil change takes about 15 minutes, and added services can add 10 to 20 minutes or more. The queue in front of you is not inside that number.

Take 5’s published claim is about 10 minutes, and it frames the number as the whole visit: most visits wrap up in about 10 minutes, from pulling in to driving off. A queue is not clearly inside that number either.

One myth to clear up while we are here: some comparison pages describe Valvoline as a visit where you hand your car over and wait. Its own store pages headline the opposite, drive-thru, stay-in-your-car oil changes. At both of these chains, you watch the work from the driver’s seat and nobody keeps your keys.

What Do Drivers Say About Valvoline and Take 5?

The biggest US dataset here is the JD Power 2026 U.S. Aftermarket Service Index Study, released April 28, 2026 and based on 10,572 vehicle owners surveyed from January to March 2026. In the quick oil change segment:

  • Take 5 scores 833 of 1,000, second in the segment.
  • Valvoline scores 823 of 1,000, tied for third.
  • The segment average is 818, so both sit above it, 10 points apart.

The recurring themes in driver reports match that near-tie. Take 5 is praised for speed and for the top-offs built into the visit, and criticised for upsell attempts in the bay. Valvoline draws the same upsell complaints.

One Valvoline complaint is specific enough to name: the reminder sticker. Valvoline’s own care team confirms in replies to customer reviews that the stickers default to 3,000 miles or 3 months, even when the car was filled with full synthetic oil, while advising drivers that they may follow their manufacturer’s recommended interval instead. If a 3,000-mile sticker lands on your windshield after a synthetic fill, that is the default setting talking, not your engine.

Valvoline or Take 5: Which One Should You Pick?

Pick Take 5 if you want the shortest, simplest visit on offer, you like the idea of top-offs handled as part of the service, and you trust the higher satisfaction score. It is the leaner product, on purpose. If Take 5 is your pick, the last step is its current offers for your store, which change by location and by month.

Pick Valvoline if you want the service written down before you arrive: a numbered check you can hold the visit to, a published quart limit with no surprises in it, and an oil you can choose by name, including a dedicated line for engines over 75,000 miles. Its network is also far larger, which matters on road trips and after a move. If Valvoline is your pick, finish with its current offers and coupons, which are set store by store.

Pick by the store if extras matter. Valvoline locations list services such as batteries and tire rotation beyond the oil change. Take 5 keeps extras to filters and wipers everywhere, with coolant exchange and state inspections at select locations. The specific bay near you decides more than the logo does.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you stay in your car at both Valvoline and Take 5?

Yes. Both chains run a drive-thru, stay-in-your-car model with no appointment. You pull in, stay in the driver’s seat while the oil change happens, and drive out.

Which is faster, Valvoline or Take 5?

Take 5 publishes the faster claim, about 10 minutes, and frames it as the whole visit. Valvoline publishes about 15 minutes for the oil change itself. Neither claim includes time spent waiting in line, so the busier store can easily be the slower visit on the day.

What does Valvoline’s 18-point check include that Take 5 does not list?

Valvoline’s published check reaches items Take 5 does not list at all, including brake fluid, automatic transmission fluid, differential fluids, a battery test at participating locations, headlights and taillights, cabin air filter, chassis lubrication and an oil change light reset. Take 5’s shorter list covers top-offs, tire pressure, and inspection of the air filter and wipers.

What brand of oil does Take 5 use?

Take 5 does not publish its oil brand. Its website lists the oil types it sells (conventional, synthetic blend, full synthetic and high mileage) and says technicians will help you pick, but it names no brand or product line. Valvoline, by contrast, publishes five named lines of its own oil.

Which chain has more locations?

Valvoline, by a wide margin. Valvoline reported more than 2,500 service centers across the US and Canada in October 2026. Take 5 reported over 1,400 locations across North America in August 2026, and its count is growing quickly.

Which one do drivers rate higher?

Take 5. In the JD Power 2026 U.S. Aftermarket Service Index Study, Take 5 scored 833 of 1,000 and placed second among quick oil change providers, while Valvoline scored 823 and tied for third. The segment average was 818.

Checked on November 13, 2026 against the companies’ own pages: Valvoline’s published maintenance check and store pages on vioc.com, its official oil store for the product lineup, Take 5’s services page on take5.com, the JD Power 2026 U.S. Aftermarket Service Index release, and both companies’ 2026 store count releases. Where a company does not publish something, this comparison says so instead of estimating it.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *